Weblog

Friday, 14 August 2009

  • Henry VI, Part 3, Act II

    http://www.william-shakespeare.info/act2-script-text-henry-vi-part3.htm

    ACT II
    SCENE I.  – a plain near Mortimer's Cross in Herefordshire.

    Enter Richard and Edward and their forces.  It has been days since the battle, yet they do not know what has become of their father (York).  They see a strange omen in the sky – three suns.  Edward interprets it as the three surviving sons of York (himself, Richard, and George) joining their lights together to over-shine the earth.  Whether he is right or not, he resolves to bear three suns on his shield from that point onward.

    A messenger brings them news of their father’s death.  And Edward’s outcry is about the most perfect description of grief I have ever read:

    “Now my soul's palace is become a prison:
    Ah, would she break from hence, that this my body
    Might in the ground be closed up in rest!
    For never henceforth shall I joy again,
    Never, O never shall I see more joy!”

    The contrast between Edward and Richard is starkly drawn.  Edward doesn’t want to hear the details and goes into a fit of passion.  Richard demands to know all.  And he refuses to display any kind of emotion.  He is saving it so that when the time for vengeance comes, he will have a reservoir of hatred on which to draw.  He says that “to weep is to make less the depth of grief.”  It’s an interesting thought, but (in my opinion), untrue.  The act of crying does release chemicals, especially stress hormones, but I would say this has more to do with enabling a person to deal with the depth of grief than with lessening the depth itself.  In either case, I think we can safely say that Richard does not have a healthy outlet for dealing with grief.  And unless he goes out and runs a mile or starts painting in the next scene, I am going to stand by that.

    Edward realizes that he is now the Duke of York, but Richard tells him not to be content with that.  The agreement made with Henry was that York would be king, followed by his heirs.  According to Richard, if Edward is truly York’s son, he will continue to fight for the crown. 

    Warwick and Montague arrive and are given the news of York’s death.  They all agree to go on with the plan, supporting Edward now in place of his father.  And just before the scene ends, a messenger comes with the news that Margaret is coming after them with a mighty host. 

     

    SCENE II – outside the city of York

    Enter Henry, Margaret, Prince Edward, Clifford, and Northumberland.  York’s head is on the gate.  The sight cheers Margaret but depresses Henry (for which Clifford chides him).  Margaret rolls her eyes at how soft Henry is and tells him to knight their son for the valour he proved in the last battle.  Henry does so.  A messenger brings the news that Warwick is leading an army in support of Edward, now Duke of York, proclaiming him king and gathering more and more followers.  Clifford and Margaret both ask Henry to leave and let them handle Warwick.  This makes by far the most sense.  Henry, far from being a military leader, does not even fight, and nothing kills the morale of an army faster than fighting for a king who stands there looking like a halibut with a secret sorrow.  But Henry refuses to leave.  He says his fortunes are on the battlefield with everyone else’s, so that is where he will stay.

     Enter Edward of York, George, Richard, Warwick, Norfolk, Montague, and their soldiers.  It’s a classic scene of trashtalking.  You know exactly how it will go, and Will does not disappoint.  Edward opens with a sneer to Henry, but it is of course Margaret who answers.  And everyone jumps in, grabbing a piece of the verbal action – everyone except Henry.  He says nothing for the rest of the scene, save for one feeble attempt to gain the floor.  “Remember, you guys, I AM the king – somebody should listen to me.”  But nobody does.


    SCENE III – a field of battle between Towton and Saxton, in Yorkshire

    Warwick sits down to catch his breath, and Edward (York) enters running.  George is close behind him.  Things are nto going well, and they are prepared to fly, but Richard comes and exhorts them all to keep fighting. 

     

    SCENE IV – another part of the field

    It’s the showdown between Clifford (who has been killing every member of the House of York he can find, to avenge his father) and the most malicious member of that House (Richard).  Before they finish it, though, Warwick shows up, and Clifford flies.  Richard tells Warwick, “Stay where you are; he’s mine!” and runs after Clifford. 

     

    SCENE V – another part of the field.

    Saddest scene of the play (possibly of any play).  Whether you love Henry or want to shake some backbone into him, this is his scene.  First of all, it’s a great soliloquy, and secondly, when other characters enter, Henry serves as observer, drawing the attention of the audience to these lesser players who would not otherwise get the same notice.  Observing an observer is a great way to see things in a new light.

    Henry is heartbroken.  Whether or not he is a good king, he is compassionate, and these are his people.  The battle is swinging back and forth, and Margaret and Clifford have finally convinced him to go off somewhere and wait it out.  So he is alone, thinking about his life, when he speaks the most famous lines of the play:

    “O God! methinks it were a happy life,
    To be no better than a homely swain;”

    And you have to feel sorry for him.  King since he was nine months old, manipulated by those closest to him, threatened and mocked and scorned for things which were not his fault, and now he sees himself responsible for the deaths of thousands of his people.  And he can’t help thinking what a great life it would be to be a shepherd – quiet, low-stress, you never let anyone down.  A simple life, even a life in poverty, if also peaceful, seems to him infinitely better than a glittering life where he can trust no one.

    “Ah, what a life were this! how sweet! how lovely!
    Gives not the hawthorn-bush a sweeter shade
    To shepherds looking on their silly sheep,
    Than doth a rich embroider'd canopy
    To kings that fear their subjects' treachery?
    O, yes, it doth; a thousand-fold it doth.
    And to conclude, the shepherd's homely curds,
    His cold thin drink out of his leather bottle.
    His wonted sleep under a fresh tree's shade,
    All which secure and sweetly he enjoys,
    Is far beyond a prince's delicates,
    His viands sparkling in a golden cup,
    His body couched in a curious bed,
    When care, mistrust, and treason waits on him.”

    Enter a young soldier, dragging a body to rifle through its pockets.  He discovers, however, that this man he has just killed is his own father.  On the other side of a stage comes an older soldier, also carrying a body he has just dispatched in order to loot it.  This time, it is the man’s son.  Both men are in agonies of grief, and Henry cries along with them as he watches, in his own words, “aid[ing] tear for tear.”  It is a perfect picture of how “unnatural” the Wars of the Roses were (and, indeed, all civil wars are) – where fathers and sons kill each other without knowing it.  Edward Duke of York and Prince Edward are both named Edward Plantagenet – it’s another family reunion gone sour, but because the family happens to be royal, everyone in the kingdom gets dragged into it.  Henry knows this, and each father and son that is killed he feels to be his own father or son. 

    Enter Margaret, Prince Edward, and Exeter.  The day has gone against them after all, and they urge Henry to escape while he can. 


    SCENE VI – another part of the field.

    Clifford has received his death wound from Richard, and he staggers onstage and collapses, waiting as the life bleeds out of him.  Like any Shakespearean character about to expire, he is still collected enough to speak cogently and at great length.  And his words about the effect his death will have on the situation are sadly accurate:

    “Here burns my candle out; ay, here it dies,
    Which, whiles it lasted, gave King Henry light.
    O Lancaster, I fear thy overthrow
    More than my body's parting with my soul!
    My love and fear glued many friends to thee;
    And, now I fall, thy tough commixture melts.”

    Many of Henry’s allies stuck with him more for Clifford’s sake than for Henry’, so things are not looking good.

    Enter Edward (York), George, Richard, Montague, and Warwick.  They are speculating on Henry’s flight and wondering if Clifford went with him.  Warwick says that this is impossible, since “Richard mark’d him for the grave.”  Clifford groans just at that moment and gives up the ghost.  They recognize him and indulge in some posthumous taunting, then cut off his head to hang on the gates of York. 

    Their plan is to march in triumph to London, crown Edward king, and then Warwick (historically known as the “kingmaker”) will go to France to get the Lady Bona for his queen.  Edward heartily approves of the plan, and creates his brother Richard Duke of Gloucester and his brother George Duke of Clarence.  Richard is displeased – he wants to be Duke of Clarence, saying “Gloucester’s dukedom is too ominous” (and who can blame him, remembering what happened to the last Duke of Gloucester?).  Warwick tuts at him for being foolish, and they proceed to London. 

    Methinks Richard would make any dukedom ominous . . .

     

    End of Act II

Monday, 10 August 2009

  • Henry VI, Part 3, Act I

    http://www.william-shakespeare.info/act1-script-text-henry-vi-part3.htm

    ACT I
    SCENE I – the parliament house in London

    You may recall that Part 2 ended with the York and Henry factions racing for London.  York arrives first, with Warwick (his ally), Montague (his brother), and Edward and Richard (two of his sons).  While they wait, they boast about their exploits in the recent battle, and who killed whom. 

    Henry arrives to find York sitting in the chair of state (“Who’s in my chair?”  “Oh, I know! Yzma!  Yzma’s in your chair!”).  It is a very tense scene (obviously).  Nothumberland, Clifford, and Westmoreland (Henry’s allies) are livid.  They are set to rush York and kill him on the spot, but Henry doesn’t want violence in the parliament house.  Neither is he about to relinquish the crown.

    “Think'st thou that I will leave my kingly throne,
    Wherein my grandsire and my father sat?
    No: first shall war unpeople this my realm;”

    Curious thing about Shakespearean kings – when they speak of war, they make it plain that they know they will be sacrificing many people for their purpose, yet it doesn’t seem to bother them.

    York (once again) explains why his claim is stronger than Henry’s.  Henry recognizes that it is and comes back with a very weak argument in his own defense (that Richard II voluntarily chose Henry Bolingbroke as his heir – which depends on how you use the word “voluntarily”). 

    Everyone sees that York’s claim is stronger (poor Exeter, the most honest man there, says it best: “My conscience tells me he is lawful king), but still no one deserts Henry.  Clifford and Northumberland and Westmoreland are so incensed (York killed relatives of theirs in Act V of Part 2) that they don’t care what kind of a claim York has so long as they get to kill him. 

    York and Henry come to an agreement: York will go home peaceably and acknowledge Henry as his king as long as Henry will name York as his heir.  They swear to it, and Henry’s allies (save for Exeter) storm out in utter disgust (and to tattle on Henry to Margaret).

    As soon as the deal is settled, York and his entourage leave.  Henry is about to leave, but he is not quite fast enough.  Margaret arrives, breathing fire. 

    Exeter: Ah, here comes the queen.  She doesn’t look overly pleased.  Well, I think I’ll just be going—

    Henry: I’ll come with you.

    Margaret: Not so fast, you gelatinous toad!

    Now, I wasn’t aware of any great passage of time during Part 2, but apparently Henry and Margaret have been married long enough that they have a son old enough to feel wronged that he will not inherit his father’s kingdom.  But if Prince Edward feels wronged, it is nothing to how Margaret feels.  She lets Henry have it with both barrels:

    “Ah, wretched man! would I had died a maid
    And never seen thee, never borne thee son,
    Seeing thou hast proved so unnatural a father.”

    “I here divorce myself
    Both from thy table, Henry, and thy bed,
    Until that act of parliament be repeal'd
    Whereby my son is disinherited.”

    And she leaves, to go lead her own army against York, taking Edward with her.  I would be tempted to say “Good riddance,” but poor dear Henry’s comment is “Poor queen!  How much she must love me and our son to be so angry on our behalf.”  Henry, Henry, Henry.  It is a wonderful thing to believe the best of people, but he could teach a doctorate level correspondence course on innocence.

     

    SCENE II – Sandal Castle

    York walks in on an argument between his brother and two of his sons.  They are not content with the terms of his agreement with Henry, and they think he should go ahead and take the kingdom by force, as was his original plan.  According to Richard’s reasoning, the oath was not binding because it was not sworn before a lawful magistrate (Henry doesn’t count as one, being an usurper).  Whether or not his argument is sound, look at his words:

    “Your oath, my lord, is vain and frivolous.
    Therefore, to arms! And, father, do but think
    How sweet a thing it is to wear a crown;
    Within whose circuit is Elysium
    And all that poets feign of bliss and joy.
    Why do we finger thus? I cannot rest
    Until the white rose that I wear be dyed
    Even in the lukewarm blood of Henry's heart.”

    More than a little disturbing.  And rightly so, for this is the boy who will become the infamous Richard III.  Crafty, well-spoken, driven by power, and very matter-of-fact about all of it.  “I cannot rest until the white rose that I wear be dyed even in the lukewarm blood of Henry’s heart.”  I have to admit that Henry comes off as having a heart of lukewarm blood.  Still, that is positively sick.  But to say something so gruesome so dispassionately . . . Richard is one of those things that is so awful you can’t not look at it. 

    York is persuaded (no one can resist Richard – just wait until he gets his own play).  But before he can do anything, he receives word that Margaret is on her way to besiege him in Sandal Castle.  Her forces vastly outnumber his own, but he goes to meet her in the field.


    SCENE III – field of battle between Sandal Castle and Wakefield

    The scene opens with Rutland (one of York’s sons) and his tutor.  Clifford (whose father was killed by York in the last battle) is bent on vengeance, but he lets the tutor go.  Rutland pleads for his life, but Clifford answers him,

    “In vain thou speak'st, poor boy; my father's blood
    Hath stopp'd the passage where thy words should enter.”

    which is a remarkably accurate assessment, both literally and figuratively.  He kills Rutland and exits in triumph.

     

    SCENE IV – another part of the field

    Enter York.  He is not having the best day.  Margaret is winning, both his uncles were killed while rescuing him, and he had to be encouraged by his sons numerous times to keep fighting.  And things are not about to get better.

    Enter Margaret, Clifford, Northumberland, and Prince Edward – probably the four people in the world who most want York dead.  Clifford and Northumberland lay hands on him, but Margaret will not let them kill him yet.  She hasn’t gotten to sneer at him yet. 

    This, ladies and gentlemen, is sarcasm.  Picture Helena Bonham Carter in this role, as derisive as she can possibly be:

    “What! was it you that would be England's king?
    Was't you that revell'd in our parliament,
    And made a preachment of your high descent?
    Where are your mess of sons to back you now?
    The wanton Edward, and the lusty George?
    And where's that valiant crook-back prodigy,
    Dicky your boy, that with his grumbling voice
    Was wont to cheer his dad in mutinies?
    Or, with the rest, where is your darling Rutland?
    Look, York: I stain'd this napkin with the blood
    That valiant Clifford, with his rapier's point,
    Made issue from the bosom of the boy;”

    I have to hand it to the woman – in terms of hateful rhetoric, she’s in a class by herself.  She places a paper crown on York’s head, mocking him as king.  “But wait!  I forgot – you weren’t supposed to be king until Henry had shook hands with death” (an excellent turn of phrase, hats off to Will).  So she takes the crown back and orders his head off with it. 

    First, York speaks.  If Margaret was hoping he would beg for his life, she is out of luck.  He insults her right down into the ground (though it doesn’t begin to compare with what she said to him), and speaks so emotionally about Rutland’s death that even Northumberland is moved to tears. 

    But Clifford and Margaret are not so moved.  They each stab him (York), and he dies.  Margaret orders that his head be set on the gates of York.  (York was originally a Viking settlement [Jorvik], so the gates would have been already fairly old and quite impressive [when the Vikings built a gate, they really built a gate].)

    End of Act I

     

    I didn’t remember that this was such an agonizing, emotionally-charged act.  It’s a bit exhausting just to read it.  It would seem that the threat to Henry is dead, but we still have four acts of madcap angst and power politics waiting.  And Henry still hasn’t gone crazy yet . . .

Friday, 31 July 2009

  • Henry VI, Part 2, Act V

    ACT V

    http://www.william-shakespeare.info/act5-script-text-henry-vi-part2.htm


    SCENE I -- Fields between Dartford and Blackheath.

    I often wonder why people say talking to yourself is unnatural when everyone does it.  Enter York.  Not only is he talking to himself, he is talking about himself (in the third person).  He goes on and on about how amazing and kingly he is, and with an army fresh from Ireland behind him, he probably looks it.

    Enter Buckingham. 

    Buckingham: York!  What in God’s name are you doing?!

    York: I intend to remove Somerset, traitor to king and country.

    Buckingham: You have no right to do so.  Besides, the king has already granted your request and thrown Somerset in the Tower.

    York: Oh, really?  Well, that’s all right, then.  (to army) Run along, boys!

    York even offers all of his sons to Henry as pledges of his good faith (this was common practice all over Europe for princes and dignitaries to exchange sons or nephews as hostages to insure good behavior).  He is, of course, bluffing.

    Enter Henry.  Buckingham relays York’s message, and it seems that everything will be smoothed over.  Enter Iden with Jack’s head.

    Henry is delighted to have the head of the traitor, and he knights Iden for his service to England. 

    Enter Margaret and Somerset.  (There is no real explanation as to why Somerset is not in the Tower.  Henry sent him there.  Somerset declared he would go gladly if was for the good of England.  Was he let out on Margaret’s authority?  The script is not clear whether or not Henry is surprised to see him or only anxious to hide him from York.)  York, upon seeing Somerset (clearly not in the Tower), is outraged.  The time has come to lay his cards on the table.  “Guess what, Henry!   You’re not worthy to be king.  You were made to serve someone like me.”

    Somerset says he arrests York for treason, but York calls for his two sons to be his bail.  Everyone gets very dramatic, and various allies appear.  Clifford and his son show up on the king’s side.  Warwick and Salisbury appear for York.  They yell back and forth, determining who has betrayed whom, and by the end of the scene, there’s nothing left to do but fight it out.

     

    SCENE II – Saint Alban's.

    Warwick is after Clifford, but York wants to be the one to kill him, so Warwick steps aside.  Clifford and York have a very interesting exchange in which they expound upon what worthy opponents they are, and how they admire and respect each other even though they are enemies.  Then Clifford dies by York’s hand.

    Enter Clifford’s son.  When he sees his father’s body, he launches into an impassioned speech about how he will show the House of York no pity, not even the children.  He carries away his father’s body, saying:

    “As did Æneas old Anchises bear,
    So bear I thee upon my manly shoulders;
    But then Æneas bare a living load,
    Nothing so heavy as these woes of mine.”

    (Slightly irrelevant remark: I do not doubt that Young Clifford means that his grief is heavy, not that a dead man weighs more than a living [though having never hefted a dead man, I could not say with any great degree of certainty].  People do seem to weigh more when they go limp, but as soon as rigormortis set it, that would be negligible.  I heard an interesting thing somewhere where scientists were trying to prove the existence of the soul and said that a person lost something like 11 ounces in the instant that he died.  Very difficult to do a study of this, of course.  If you go around asking people at death’s door to hop on a scale, you will get some dirty looks.  But still . . . does your soul weigh 11 ounces?)

    The next to die is Somerset, slain by Richard (son of York). 

    After more nondescript fighting ,we see Henry and Margaret.  Margaret is urging Henry to run.  It’s not as if he’s fighting anyway, and if he can make it to London, where he has the support of the people, it is likely that things could still turn out in his favour.  Young Clifford enters and adds his pleas to Margaret’s.  He says that normally, he would say to fight to the death, but he hopes to pay these rascals back on another day, and the only way to do that is if Henry survives.  And Henry finally assents.

     

    SCENE III – Fields near St. Alban’s

    The York contingent regroups and congratulates themselves on their victory.  Aware of the king’s movements, they set off for London with all speed, hoping to beat him there.

     

    End of Act V.

    As with any trilogy, the middle installment has no kind of ending at all – curtains are not supposed to close on the middle of a race to London. 

    A line from Richard:
    “Priests pray for enemies, but princes kill.”

    So often true, even today in places where princes are “chosen” by the people.  To indulge in a Socratic moment, do they kill because they are princes, or are they princes because they kill?

     

    I won’t be able to start the third play until (probably) Wednesday, but feel free to read ahead!

Thursday, 30 July 2009

  • Henry VI, Part 2, Act IV

    ACT IV

    http://www.william-shakespeare.info/act4-script-text-henry-vi-part2.htm


    SCENE I – the coast of Kent.

    Suffolk is not having the best day.  He is leaving England to begin his exile, and he is captured by pirates.  He promises them that he is a gentleman, so there is no need to kill him as his ransom will be paid.  But he is startled to learn the name of his captor (Walter Whitmore), because it was foretold to him that he would die at sea at the hands of a man named Walter.   The pirate captain is determined he should die, gentleman or not, and Suffolk retorts:

    “Obscure and lowly swain, King Henry’s blood, the honourable blood of Lancaster, must not be shed by such a jaded groom.”

    Rather tactless, considering.  Free advice for the day: if a pirate is ever waffling over whether or not to kill you, calling him an “obscure and lowly swain” might not be the best move.

    In any case, he hasn’t a hope, because the captain knows who he is and what he has done and despises him for it.  Good-bye Suffolk.

     

    Scene II – Blackheath

    A word about Jack Cade: In this play, Jack Cade marches on London with an army of Kentish peasants and the intention of declaring himself king.  He claims connection to the Mortimer family, saying that the Duke of Clarence’s daughter had twins, and the elder was stolen in infancy by a beggar-woman, and that child grew up to be Jack’s father.  Notice that York’s claim to the crown is through this same family, and in the last act, York spoke as if he were the one inciting Jack to revolt.  In real life, Jack Cade may very well have been of the Mortimer line, but when he marched on London, it was not with intent to usurp.  The people of England were tired of Henry’s apparent weakness, overtaxing and governmental corruption, and the loss of France, and those of Kent wrote up a manifesto of grievances which they came to London to present.  This group was made up of more than peasants – the lists of those pardoned bear the names of MPs, knights, lords, and townsmen.  And whether or not Jack Cade was a descendant of Edward III (or was as hilarious as he is in this play), he certainly led the ‘rebellion.’

    Jack is addressing the masses of Kentish peasants with his faithful cronies at his side.  He spells out his lineage and also what changes he will make when he has taken over England.  (This is an election speech, and though Jack is nothing like Pedro or Napoleon, his speech has a certain “If you vote for me, all of your wildest dreams will come true” ring to it.)  When he is king, seven halfpenny loaves will sell for a penny, three-hooped pots shall have ten hoops, and (my favourite) “[he] will make it a felony to drink small beer.”  This fictional version of Jack is also apparently socialist, promising that everything in England will be held in common.

    And now it falls to Dick to utter the most famous line of the play:  “The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.”

    Jack’s response is fascinating.  First, he says that he means to do that personally (like Peter Pan saying to the lost boys, “Hook is mine!”).  But his comments about writing and more specifically, signing one’s name to something, are quite telling.  It was not uncommon for illiterate people to cringe from signing their name to something, because in their way of thinking, it trapped them, and they didn’t know how.  As Jack says, “Is not this a lamentable thing, that of the skin of an innocent lamb should be made parchment? that parchment, being scribbled o’er, should undo a man?  Some say the bee stings; but I say, ‘tis the bee’s wax; for I did but seal once to a thing, and I was never mine own man since.”  (Funniest account of this phenomenon I have read to date is in The Wee Free Men by Terry Pratchett.)

    The Clerk of Chatham is brought forward, and Jack sentences him as a traitor because he can write.

    Enter Michael.  He urges Jack to fly because Sir Humphrey Stafford and his brother are coming with the king’s forces to put down the revolt.  And this brings on the best Jack Cade moment in the play – he kneels down and knights himself (saying, “Rise up Sir John Mortimer) in order to meet Sir Humphrey as an equal.  It’s almost better than Bonaparte setting the crown on his own head.

    Enter Humphrey and William Stafford.  They charge the peasants to go home, promising that Henry will forgive them if they disband now.  Jack steps up and declares to the Stafford brothers that he is the rightful king of England.  Then he outlines his family tree once again, complete with the unlikely story about the beggar-woman.

    William: York told you to say this, didn’t he.

    Jack:(aside) That’s not true!  I made up all of it myself!

    Jack says that they want Lord Saye’s head (Lord High Treasurer) for “selling the dukedom of Maine.”  Lord Saye did nothing of the sort (Suffolk sold it, if anyone), but Jack is determined he is a traitor because he speaks French.


    SCENE III – Blackheath

    A fight scene, in which both Stafford brothers are slain.  Jack congratulates Dick for killing people as if were in his butcher shop back home, and they march toward London.

     

    SCENE IV – London, the palace

    Enter Henry and Margaret (each holding something noteworthy), Buckingham, and the unfortunate Lord Saye.  Henry is perusing a supplication, and this is probably meant to be the list of grievances from the people of Kent (The Complaint of the Poor Commons of Kent being its official title).  Henry hopes to be able to parley with Jack, because he doesn’t want people to get killed over this. 

    The pirates from Scene I have very thoughtfully sent Suffolk’s head to Margaret.  (Aside* -- a very amusing way to visualize the characters: Margaret reminds me quite of bit of Margaret Hoolihan of the 4077th.  Then of course, we have a pushover of a Henry in the cast.  And if Suffolk’s Christian named happened to be Frank, that would just be uncanny.)  Margaret is clutching the head and wailing over it, and Henry says to her, “If I were dead, you wouldn’t mourn so much for me.”  Margaret may be insincere and manipulative, but you have to admit that she’s quick: “No, my love, I should not mourn, but die for thee.”

    A messenger enters with the news that the rebels are in Southwark, have already killed the Stafford brothers, and intend to kill all scholars, lawyers, courtiers and gentlemen on which they can lay hands.  Henry runs off to Killingworth for the time being.  He entreats Lord Saye to accompany him (since Saye is the one Jack most wants dead), but Lord Saye is determined to stay in London.  

    Another messenger enters.  Jack has taken London Bridge, and the rebels are up in arms to sack the city. 


    SCENE V – London.  The Tower.

    This is a very short scene, showing the fear and uncertainty of the Londoners in this situation.  Jack has already tried to win the Tower, and the lord mayor of London is looking for help wherever he can find it.


    SCENE VI – London. Cannon Street.

    This scene opens with Jack striking his staff on London Stone.  This is historically accurate.  According to legend, London was founded by Brutus of Troy, and he placed London Stone there as part of an altar, saying,
    "So long as the stone of Brutus is safe, so long shall London flourish."  It was thought to be the spot from which the Romans reckoned all distances in Britannia and was considered to be a symbolic source of authority and the heart of London itself for centuries afterward.  Jack Cade did indeed strike his staff against it (it was then set in the middle of Cannon Street – later it was built into the wall of St. Swithin’s Church, and though the church was bombed in the second world war, the stone escaped unscathed) to declare himself lord mayor of London.  The original audience of this play would have known all of this and would have been waiting for this scene ever since Jack came into the play.

    Jack declares himself lord of the city, proclaiming that for the first year of his reign, the sewage drains will run with nothing but claret wine (good luck).  He also says that, henceforward, it will be treason for anyone to call him anything other than Lord Mortimer. 

    Right on cue, a man comes running in yelling “Jack Cade!  Jack Cade!” and Jack has him killed on the spot.

    Dick informs him that there is an army waiting for them at Smithfield.  Jack is only too happy to go fight them, as long as he can try to burn down the Tower (just for laughs) on his way there.

     

    SCENE VII – London. Smithfield.

    There are a lot of individual lines which I would like to point out in this scene, but I will try and restrain myself.  The rebels win at Smithfield, and Lord Saye is discovered and brought before Jack.  Saye pleads for his life, but Jack has him killed anyway.  Here are a few of his reasons:

    “Thou hast most traitorously
    corrupted the youth of the realm in erecting a
    grammar school”

    “It will be proved to thy face that thou
    hast men about thee that usually talk of a noun and
    a verb, and such abominable words as no Christian
    ear can endure to hear.”

    These sound suspiciously like the reasons Socrates was killed (“corrupting the youth”).

    Saye is killed, and Jack orders his men to hunt down Saye’s son-in-law (Sir James Cromer) and kill him as well, and then bring back their heads on poles.  Then the rebels parade through the streets of London, making the heads kiss each other at every corner (sad to say, this is also historically accurate).


    SCENE VIII – Southwark.

    Jack & Co. are storming through the city, sacking and killing as they go.  Buckingham and Clifford come to sound a parley and address the rebels.  They say that Henry will offer free pardon to anyone who will leave Jack that moment and go home.  You can see the masses of Kentishmen pause, look at each other, then all start crying “God save the king!  God save the king!”  Jack bursts out with, “What?!  You actually believe that, you pack of idiots?  If you turn back now, you’ll either be hanged or just go back to the slavery you were in before!”  So of course they all change their minds and cry “We’ll follow Cade, we’ll follow Cade!”

    Clifford points out that Henry has money and is the son of the man who conquered France, so it’s pretty much in the bag that he will win if they choose to fight him.  Seeing the truth of this, the rebels switch back to the king’s side. 

    Disgusted with their fickleness, and seeing that he has been abandoned, Jack flees.  Buckingham offers a reward of 100,000 crowns for him (which, first of all, is impossible, since the crown was not introduced until Henry VIII’s monetary reform, but when converted to present-day US currency [using a VERY conservative estimate of inflation] could not possibly be less than 25 grand).  


    SCENE IX – Kenilworth Castle

    Henry’s opening speech is the single best illustration of his situation and the ‘tragedy’ of the play:

    “Was ever king that joy'd an earthly throne,
    And could command no more content than I?
    No sooner was I crept out of my cradle
    But I was made a king, at nine months old.
    Was never subject long'd to be a king
    As I do long and wish to be a subject.”

    Buckingham and Clifford enter with the horde of Kentish rebels, all of whom Henry pardons. 

    Enter a messenger.  York has returned from Ireland and is marching on London, stating that he comes only to remove Somerset, whom he says is a traitor.  And if anyone believes that . . . well, it is sweet to see that there is still some innocence in the world.  Henry asks Buckingham to go meet York and ask him what he wants.  Meanwhile, he will send Somerset to the Tower, hoping York will be pacified. 


    SCENE X – Kent. Iden’s garden.

    Jack has been hiding in the woods and hasn’t eaten for five days, so he sneaks into someone’s garden in the hopes of finding food.  The garden belongs to a chap named Iden, who conveniently enters at this moment and gives a charming little speech about how content he is with his country life.  As you may have guessed from his earlier actions, Jack isn’t all there.  He assumes Iden has come to seize him and turn him in to the king, so he begins trashtalking Iden, saying “I’m going to kill you.”  His actual words make me laugh every time:

    “if I do not leave you as dead as a doornail, I pray God I may never eat grass more.”

    Okay then, Jack.  Did you really love eating grass that much anyway?

    Iden doesn’t know what to make of it.  The man is trespassing in his garden, is abominably rude to him, and now wants to fight him.  Iden doesn’t want to fight a man who hasn’t eaten in five days, so he tries to point out to Jack that he has the obvious advantage (in size as well).  Jack doesn’t care.  So they fight, and Jack gets himself killed.  And with his last breath, he makes excuses for himself: “I never would have lost if I had eaten in the last five days!”

    Once Iden realizes who Jack is, he determines that he shall never clean his sword, because the sword that killed Jack Cade is quite a trophy.  Then he tells Jack’s corpse exactly how he intends to desecrate his body and bear his head in triumph to the king.  Lovely sentiments.

     

    End of Act IV.

Tuesday, 28 July 2009

  • Henry VI, Part 2, Act III

    ACT III (in which things happen very quickly)

    http://www.william-shakespeare.info/act3-script-text-henry-vi-part2.htm


    SCENE I – the Abbey at Bury St. Edmund's.

    Enter Henry, Margaret, Cardinal Beaufort, Suffolk, York, Buckingham, Salisbury, and Warwick.  They have gathered for the parliament, and Henry wonders why Gloucester is late.  Margaret is only too happy to give an answer.  According to her, he has become insolent of late.  He is an enemy to Henry and wants to have him disposed of, because he (Gloucester) is next in line to the crown.  Suffolk confirms her analysis, and the others chip in as well, accusing Gloucester of judging misdemeanors too harshly and of overtaxing all of England to pay for the French war, yet never sending any of the money to France. 

    In Suffolk’s speech, you will find the origin of the saying, “smooth waters run deep.”  What Suffolk actually says is, “Smooth runs the water where the brook is deep.”  The meaning of this phrase has altered significantly since Suffolk said it, though.  Today, we mean that those tending toward taciturnity are the most profound.  Suffolk means, though, that those who are plotting treachery are careful not to draw attention to themselves: “The fox barks not when he would steal the lamb.”

    Henry maintains that Gloucester is virtuous, mild, and innocent of any and all offenses. 

    Enter Somerset with the news that France is utterly lost.   

    Enter Gloucester.  And Suffolk arrests him for high treason.  When Gloucester asks why, York accuses him of accepting bribes from France and of keeping the soldiers’ pay for himself, thereby making him responsible for the loss of France.  This is absurd.  As Gloucester protests, he gave a great deal of money from his own estate toward the war effort so that he would not have to tax the people more than necessary.  York proceeds to accuse him of “devis[ing] strange tortures for offenders never heard of, that England was defamed by tyranny.”  This, too, is ludicrous.  Gloucester says that, if anything, he was too lenient. 

    Henry is convinced of Gloucester’s innocence, but he does nothing.  King he may be, but he lets them take Gloucester away to face trial.  As soon as Gloucester leaves, he excuses himself, too overcome with grief to go on with the parliament.  And his exit speech is truly painful.  Firstly, because he describes his current emotional state so vividly (“my body round engirt with misery”), and secondly because he goes on and on about how Gloucester never hurt anyone, yet all the lords and queen Margaret have turned on him, and now he has been taken away like a calf to the butcher’s block, and I just want to yell at him, “Henry!  Let’s pretend for one moment that you’re the king and can do something about injustice, shall we?”

    Exeunt all but Margaret, Cardinal Beaufort, Suffolk, and York.  Somerset remains apart.

    Margaret says that her husband is “too full of foolish pity, and Gloucester’s show beguiles him as the mournful crocodile with sorrow snares relenting passengers.”  (I find it fascinating that Elizabethan Britons had the saying “crocodile tears.”  Globalization is not a recent phenomenon,  my friends.)  They all agree that Gloucester will be dangerous until he is dead.  After all, Henry is on his side, and the vast majority of the English people.   So they decide to kill him before his trial. 

    Enter a messenger with the news that Ireland is in revolt (which comes as no surprise to anyone).  York, the epitome of sarcasm, suggests that Somerset be sent to Ireland as regent, since he had such marvelous success in France.  They begin bickering – Somerset saying he lasted longer in France than York would have done, York saying he would have died before losing France and dishonouring himself. 

    Cardinal Beaufort suggests that York be the one to subdue Ireland.  He implies that, in this way, he can prove he would have succeeded where Somerset failed.   Another possible motive is that Beaufort is always trying to eliminate rivals, and York in Ireland is much less of a threat to his power than York in London.

    But this plays directly into York’s hand.  He will be provided with soldiers before he sails for Ireland, and soldiers were the one thing he lacked to stage a coup against Henry.


    SCENE II – Bury St. Edmund's. A room of state.

    First Murderer: “Run to my Lord of Suffolk; let him know

    We have dispatch'd the duke, as he commanded.”

    (Didst thou ever hear a murderer who spoke with such elegance?  Using such a polite euphemism for bumping someone off?)

    Second Murderer: “O that it were to do! What have we done?

    Didst ever hear a man so penitent?”

    (“O that it were to do!” = O that the deed lay still before us, that we might choose differently)

     

    Enter Suffolk.  He confers briefly with his assassins, promising they will be paid, and they exit.  Enter Henry, Margaret, Cardinal Beaufort, and Somerset.  The time has come for Gloucester’s trial, and Suffolk goes to fetch him.  He re-enters, pretending to be all shaken up, and announces that Gloucester is dead.  The Cardinal sticks in a snide comment that this is God’s secret judgment, and Henry faints dead away. 

    When he comes to, he begins railing at Suffolk for bringing such terrible news, and Margaret instantly comes to Suffolk’s defense.  This is the part at which I just want to gag her.  First she goes on and on about how Gloucester was an enemy to Suffolk, yet Suffolk “most Christian-like laments his death.”  She says the same thing about herself.  Gloucester was her enemy, but she is only too happy for cry for him.  And then she really goes off the deep end and turns it into a “you don’t love me!” speech.  She says she is even more wretched that Gloucester, because she went through so much suffering to come to Henry and he his queen, and he has a “flinty heart” and does not appreciate her.  (Meg.  Sweetheart.  Could you please try and stick to the subject?)

    Enter Warwick, Salisbury, and a horde of commoners.  Warwick says that according to local gossip, Gloucester is dead by Suffolk and Beaufort’s hands, and the commoners are up in arms about it.  Henry informs him that Gloucester is indeed dead, but he doesn’t know how.  Warwick goes to inspect the corpse.

    Re-enter Warwick with Gloucester’s mortal remains.  Warwick performs a quick autopsy in the king’s presence to convince him that Gloucester was murdered.  In Warwick’s reasoning, a person who dies of natural causes is usually pale, because the heart – labouring so intensely at the end – draws all the blood to itself.  Gloucester’s face is positively black with all the blood settled there.  His eyeballs are slightly popped , his fingers spread, his nostrils stretched with struggling (I know.  I’m a bit skeptical myself, but Warwick is a fictional character in a 400-year-old play, so you can’t challenge him on it).  All the signs point to the conclusion that that he was murdered.

    SUFFOLK 
    Why, Warwick, who should do the duke to death?
    Myself and Beaufort had him in protection;
    And we, I hope, sir, are no murderers.

    WARWICK 
    But both of you were vow'd Duke Humphrey's foes,
    And you, forsooth, had the good duke to keep:
    'Tis like you would not feast him like a friend;
    And 'tis well seen he found an enemy.

    Suffolk is not about to take a murder accusation lying down (however just it may be).  He says that Warwick’s mother must have slept with some low-born villain to produce him.  And Warwick’s answer is impressive in both dignity and contempt.  He says that he would make Suffolk beg forgiveness for that speech, and say it was his own mother he meant, but two things stop him: 1) he is in the presence of his sovereign, and 2) if he killed Suffolk outright, it would deny him the pleasure of seeing him executed shamefully as a murderer.  And he calls Suffolk a “pernicious blood-sucker of sleeping men.”  (Like I said, these people really know how to insult each other.)

    They exit, but re-enter almost immediately, weapons drawn.  This is illegal in the king’s presence, but Suffolk cries that Warwick and all the men of Bury set upon him.  Salisbury calls to the commoners to be still and wait for the king to hear their complaint.  They want Suffolk dead, or at least banished.  They know he killed Gloucester, and they fear he will also kill Henry, so the mob is there out of love for their king (so Salisbury says). 

    Henry’s response is probably his most regal moment in all three plays.  He does indeed banish Suffolk. 

    “by His majesty I swear,

    Whose far unworthy deputy I am,   [this is a foundational concept of the Divine Right of Kings – that the earthly king was an anointed deputy of God]

    He [Suffolk] shall not breathe infection in this air

    But three days longer, on the pain of death.”


    Yes, Henry, you may take a bow.  Thank you for standing up and being a man.


    Now Margaret and Suffolk have their good-bye scene (after everyone else has left).  It is both volatile and poetic, and since they are both vile characters, the scene’s appeal is based entirely on the beauty of the verbal imagery and the intricacy of the words. 

    Vaux enters with the news that Cardinal Beaufort has been taken suddenly and violently ill, and he leaves again to bear this message to the king.  Margaret and Suffolk indulge in yet another fling of good-byes (in which Suffolk outdoes even his earlier efforts), and they finally exit. 


    SCENE III – a bedchamber.

    Enter Henry, Salisbury, and Warwick.  Cardinal Beaufort is already there, dying.

    This is a fairly short death scene, but it exemplifies that idea of that time that a man who feared death or died ‘badly’ was surely a villain.  At the last, Henry begs Beaufort to hold up his hand as a sign that his trust is in God, but Beaufort dies without making such a sign.  And Henry is his usual sanctimonious self as he closes the scene:

    “Forbear to judge, for we are sinners all.
    Close up his eyes and draw the curtain close;
    And let us all to meditation.”

     

    End of Act III.


    Who will die next?  I confess, I wouldn’t be opposed to someone slipping Margaret some arsenic, but I fear we shall have to endure her for yet some time.  

dwarfishracket

  • Visit dwarfishracket's Xanga Site
    • Member Since: 1/8/2008

Weblog Archives

Don't worry - your calendar is here… to see it in action just click "Save" above and refresh the page.

About Me

[no info]

Blogrings

[no blogrings]

Pulse

dwarfishracket has no pulse!...